Picky eaters: My toddler is a picky eater

Picky eaters: My toddler is a picky eater

Picky eating is common among young children. You may want to think of it as part of their quest to be independent. Find out more.

Many preschoolers are now actually good company at mealtime. They generally view eating as a natural response to hunger and meals as a pleasant social experience.

On the other hand, it is also common for three- to five-year-olds to develop (seemingly overnight) specific food preferences. In some cases, they'll eat only yellow foods or foods covered completely with applesauce. In other cases, the selection shrinks to five foods total, one of them potato chips. That can be frustrating, to say the least.

One thing a parent needs to accept Inconsistency rules the day, so don't get flustered. Your child may be less hungry some days because she was less active the day before. She may have seen another child eating something you'd never think of feeding her for dinner, such as a jelly doughnut. Take heart: When children are stubborn about eating at this age, it is part of learning to be independent and in control.

Control and more control
Children often use food to display control, which is natural in a preschooler. Even at the height of these difficult periods, children will not starve themselves and they rarely lose weight. However, if you do suspect weight loss, or if you notice other symptoms of illness such as fever, nausea, or diarrhea along with a sudden change in appetite, you should consult your healthcare provider.

Mealtime strategies that work
Here are some strategies to help you and your child have more pleasant mealtimes:

  • Offer your child nutritious foods and let her decide what and how much to eat. You are the supply agent, and she is the eater. You are in control of what's in the house and on the table; she's in control of what goes in her mouth.
  • Anticipate that she will imitate her peers with regard to likes and dislikes and that these will change constantly.
  • Battles about food are common, and eating gets lost in the struggle. These are really about control. Know what you can and cannot control.
  • The best advice is for parents and other frequent caregivers to be good role models. Children will eat in whatever way their family does, eventually.
  • Practice healthy eating behaviors, including serving/choosing a variety of foods, trying new foods, and not overeating.
  • Try to eat meals together as a family whenever possible.
  • Foster a relaxed atmosphere at mealtimes, and try not to rush your child. On the other hand, if she takes longer than 30 minutes to finish, she's not really hungry, so give it up.

Eating for life
The basic eating habits your child develops now will probably stay with him the rest of his life. The following are general guidelines to help your child get enough (but not too much) food. Remember that quantities and selections may vary from day to day.

1. Offer small portions, with seconds only if your child asks for them.

A few acceptable child-sized portions include:

  • 4-6 ounces of milk or juice
  • 1 slice toast
  • 1/2 cup yogurt or cottage cheese
  • 4 tablespoons vegetables
  • 2 ounces hamburger
  • 1/2 cup cereal

2. Limit snacks to three per day, stressing lower-fat foods, fruit, and fresh vegetables over soft drinks, candy, pastries, and salty or greasy items. Additional snacks may decrease your child's appetite for meals. Plan the time for snacks and avoid grazing.

Nutritious snack foods for preschoolers include:

  • Fruit
  • Fruit juices (limit juice to 4 to 6 ounces a day)
  • Carrot, celery, or cucumber sticks
  • Cheese sticks
  • Yogurt
  • Toast or crackers with cheese
  • Oatmeal cookies
  • Finger sandwiches (meaning 1/8 of a sandwich), or bran muffins

3. Make sure your child is actually hungry or thirsty when she asks for food or a drink. She may just want some attention, so try talking or playing first. Try not to use food as a pacifier.

4. Limit milk intake at this age to 16 ounces a day. Milk is a very important food, but too much of it may reduce your child's appetite for other important foods.

5. Encourage your child to try new foods by offering small amounts to taste, not by insisting that she eat a full portion of an unfamiliar food. It takes seven tastes, on average, before a child will accept a new food.

6. Discourage eating while distracted by the television, games or stories. These other activities are distracting. In addition, television advertising is influential in the choices your child makes about food.  Children this age are receptive to plugs for sugary cereals and sweets, especially after they've visited other homes where these foods are served. Less than 5 percent of food ads during the daytime are for "good" foods such as fruits and vegetables. The more commercial television children watch, the more likely they are to demand less nutritious snacks and be less interested in healthier alternatives.

7. Let your child help choose and prepare food. Kids love to help and will feel proud to have contributed.

8. Encourage conversation when everyone’s at the table. Nothing like a pleasant atmosphere to aid digestion!

Consistent weight gain and proportional height and weight are the best markers of good nutrition. Keep up regular health check-ups and look at the growth charts at the health provider's office for reassurance.

Leave a comment *Mandatory text
I confirm I have written the entirety of the content and agree to the community guidelines and terms and conditions
  • Show comments

Struggling through the phase


This article mad me feel a bit better about my daughter's picky eating. She will literally only eat like 4 foods, everything else gets spit out or very carefully picked out and handed back to mommy or daddy. It has been going on for almost 10 months, and it is driving me crazy!

Frustrating but it will pass


This stage is so frustrating when I know he used to eat absolutely everything. I take heart that it is about power and will pass, eventually.

Eathing vegetables


So my baby used to love vegetables, now I cant even try to give him any he just spits them out with in seconds.



Control is definitely the issue with my 3-year-old. I try to give her choices as much as possible.

Picky Eating

Brandy 7/30/2015

My 2 yr old is definitely in this stage. I have to beg her to try new stuff and she will finally say "alright just a bite." Most of the stuff she use to love she will not touch anymore.

Teaching Sleeping Habits: Toddler Sleep Training

Many a toddler will do anything to avoid falling asleep ⎯ crying, asking for drinks of water, even getting out of bed. Follow these guidelines to help with toddler sleep training.

Read more

Crybabies: why do some babies cry more than others?

You might ask yourself why your baby cries so much. Here’s what you can do to soothe your baby and relieve your own stress.

Read more

Housework with Toddlers

Since our kids like to imitate us, why not show them ways to help around the house? Some easy chores kids can do (with parental supervision) include dusting, watering plants and sorting laundry. Get more ideas.

Read more