skip to navigation
Pampers® Village a place to grow

Expert Q&A:
What's the best way to handle a 3-year-old's lies?

0   people commented
on this article
 
0
 
0
Lawrence Kutner
Answered by Lawrence Kutner Ph.D.
"I'm a clinical psychologist, a consultant, and a journalist," says Lawrence Kutner, "which is a great combination for someone who's nosy."

Lawrence Kutner, Ph.D. (www.drkutner.com), is a nationally known clinical psychologist who trained at the Mayo Clinic. From 1987 to 1994 he wrote the award-winning, weekly New York Times column "Parent &; Child," which was syndicated globally. From 1991 to 1999 he was the child behavior and "Ask the Expert" columnist for Parents magazine. He's also a former talk show host on KGO radio in San Francisco.

He is on the psychiatry faculty of Harvard Medical School and Massachusetts General Hospital, where he is co-director of the Harvard Medical School Center for Mental Health and Media. In addition, he's on the board of advisors to the Rosalynn Carter Mental Health Journalism Fellowship Program at the Carter Center in Atlanta.

Dr. Kutner has been a consultant to the Children's Television Workshop, the Johann Jacobs Foundation (Zurich), the Sexuality Information and Education Council of the United States, and to major universities and corporations throughout the United States and Europe. He is a frequent guest on national television and radio networks. He received his bachelor's degree from Oberlin College in Ohio and his Ph.D. in clinical psychology from the University of Minnesota. His recent books include Parent &; Child: Getting Through to Each Other, Pregnancy and Your Baby's First Year, Toddlers and Preschoolers, Your School-Age Child, Making Sense of Your Teenager, and Grand Theft Childhood: The Surprising Truth About Violent Video Games and What Parents Can Do.

Dr. Kutner is the father of a 18-year-old son as well as a 30-year-old foster son from Romania. He and his family live outside of Boston, Massachusetts.
Read bio Hide bio Hide

Question


My 3-year-old lies constantly. She also blames her little sister for the things she's done. How should I handle this?

Answer


Congratulations. You have a smart child!

While telling bald-faced lies is a sign of problems in an adult or even in an older child, among toddlers and preschoolers it's a reflection of social sophistication and abstract thinking. Let me explain.

 



A lie is simply a solution to a problem. It's the best solution that the child (or adult) can come up with at the time. But before she offers a solution, she has to realize that there's a problem. That's why I say that lying can be a sign of good things in young children.

 



Children your daughter's age have difficulty telling the difference between fantasy and reality. The thought that a carpet can fly through the air is no stranger to her at that age than the thought that a picture appears when you turn on a television set. So some lies are simply a natural intrusion of fantasy onto reality.

 



Other lies show an awareness of consequences, which is both an early form of abstract thinking and a social skill. If I poured strawberry jam on the cat and now Mom looks upset, I can anticipate that she'll be angry with me if I say that I did it. So I'll lie, and blame my sister. There's no real malice here; it's simply the best way I can use my social and verbal skills to ward off potential trouble. In this case, the lie is a sign of maturity. It's something I wouldn't have done a few months ago.

 



Meanwhile, don't view this as a character defect. If you know that she's lying, tell her so without calling her a bad person. Keep your focus on the problem —the spilled jam —and have her help you clean it up as best she can.

 



Some of this type of lying will go away naturally as your daughter grows older and learns other ways to solve problems. She'll also become more skilled at lying, which is a good thing —especially when she has to smile sweetly and thank her aunt for giving her socks for Christmas when what she really wanted was a video game!

 

ADVERTISEMENT
 
 
0
Member comments

You might also like

Helps potty training make sense during the day and protects against leaks at night

Find out about: Easy Ups Trainers for Boys
Easy Ups Trainers for Boys